George
Siemens (2008) describes four metaphors of educators. These metaphors describe different ways an
educator can influence the learning of their students. He states that each metaphor or approach
would have value in different situations.
Educators must evaluate the learning experience to determine which
metaphor would best fit the experience.
One metaphor describes the educator as a master
artist. In this context, the teacher
observes and allows students to learn not only from the instructor but also
from other students. There are times
when students can learn best from their peers.
I have witnessed where a teacher struggled to reach a student yet a
fellow classmate was able to help the student understand the concept. Even though the metaphor has truth to it,
educators must always be ready to redirect peer tutoring when necessary.
The next metaphor refers to the teacher as a network
administrator. In this scenario, the
teacher helps the learner to form connections and create learning networks. These networks would help students “in
developing competence to meet the objectives or outcomes” (Siemens, 2008, p.
16). This role of the educator
“encourages” their students to “critically evaluate the sources suitability”
(2008, p.16). In this era, students need
skills that will help them to determine if the information on the web is
accurate. The role of a network
administrator is needed in order to teach the skills needed to navigate in the
networks that are available in today’s world.
The next metaphor describes the teacher’s role as a
concierge. As a concierge, the teacher
opens the door to the many learning possibilities students may not know that
are available to them (2008). In this
role, the teacher may move between traditional lectures to free exploration.
The
last metaphor of the educator is a curator.
Teacher must fulfill two roles.
They are the expert, but they are also a guide. In this metaphor, the teacher creates an
atmosphere where learners are exposed to ideas, concepts, and papers. The teacher also knows that there should be a
balance between giving the student freedom to explore the concepts and teacher
guidance (2008).
The
concierge metaphor would best fit my view of the role of instructors. As I reflected over the different metaphors,
the concierge metaphor encompasses many of the key points included in the other
three. Great concierges are the masters
of their surroundings. They know the ins
and outs of their town (topic). They
observe the people they serve and know when they need guidance. Concierges also know how to build networks
and help those around them to navigate those networks.
References